Nalqerio study · November 2026

Study: Which painters, electricians and plumbers do ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google recommend?

People looking for a painter, electrician or plumber increasingly ask an AI assistant – or read the AI answer at the top of Google. We wanted to know which trade businesses ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overview name, and what they rely on. So we asked one question per trade in Germany’s ten largest cities and analysed 120 answers.

By Nalqerio · Created with AI assistancePublished on 7 November 20269 min read

What you will take away

The four AI systems almost never agreed: for 90% of the 303 businesses named, only one system named them for the same question, and no business was named by all four. ChatGPT usually named exactly one business, Google AI Overview 4.5 on average. Roughly half of the cited sources were directories and portals, for Perplexity even 82%. At the end you will find the 31 businesses that at least two AIs named.

The key findings at a glance

  • No business named by all four: for none of the 30 questions did all four systems name the same business. 272 of the 303 businesses named (90%) came from only one system.
  • ChatGPT usually names one business: exactly one in 24 of 30 answers, 1.2 on average. Gemini named 3.4 on average, Perplexity 2.4 and Google AI Overview 4.5.
  • Google always shows an AI answer and a map: all 30 Google searches showed an AI Overview and a map with four businesses; 27 AI Overviews named specific businesses.
  • Portals make up almost half of the sources: 49% of the 354 cited sources were directories, review and city portals – 82% for Perplexity.
  • Least agreement for plumbers: only one system named 94% of them, compared with 85% of painters.

How we measured

On 1 November 2026 we asked one question per trade in Germany’s ten largest cities – Berlin, Hamburg, Munich, Cologne, Frankfurt am Main, Düsseldorf, Stuttgart, Leipzig, Dortmund and Essen – in German, the way customers ask:

  • “Which painting business in [city] can you recommend?”
  • “Which electrician in [city] can you recommend?”
  • “Which plumbing business in [city] can you recommend?”

Each of the 30 questions went once to ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, each through the provider’s API with web search; for Gemini, Perplexity provides the web search in this measurement. For Google AI Overview we ran the question as a Google search and evaluated the AI Overview on the results page. All 120 answers are available.

From every answer we took the businesses named. We merged the same business written slightly differently per question and did not count addresses or portals as businesses. The measurement is a snapshot, not a representative market picture. In our web agency study the same AI named only 35% of the providers again one week later.

Bar chart: 90 percent of the trade businesses were named by only one of the four AI systems, 10 percent by two, 1 percent by three and none by all four.
Own analysis of 120 answers from 1 November 2026 (10 cities × 3 trades × 4 AI systems). Explore this in the product tour: Seven product areas, one clear workflow

Four AIs, hardly any shared recommendation

For the same question, the four systems almost always named different businesses. Together the 120 answers contained 344 mentions. Merging the same businesses per question leaves 303: 272 of them were named by only one system, 29 by two and just 2 by three. No question had a business named by all four.

Bar chart: 90 percent of the trade businesses were named by only one of the four AI systems, 10 percent by two, 1 percent by three and none by all four.
Businesses named across 30 questions, same names merged per question. Own analysis from 1 November 2026.

For 19 of the 30 questions at least two systems named a shared business; for 11 questions there was no overlap at all. For a trade business this means: being named by ChatGPT does not mean being named by Google or Perplexity – and vice versa.

ChatGPT usually names just one business

The systems name very different numbers of businesses. ChatGPT recommended exactly one business in 24 of 30 answers, otherwise two – 1.2 on average. Gemini named 3.4 on average, Perplexity 2.4 and Google AI Overview 4.5.

Bar chart: businesses named per answer on average: ChatGPT 1.2, Gemini 3.4, Perplexity 2.4, Google AI Overview 4.5.
30 answers per AI system. Own analysis from 1 November 2026.

With ChatGPT the competition for the one named spot is therefore especially tough. If you are not that one business, you do not appear in the answer at all.

Google always shows an AI answer and a map

All 30 Google searches showed an AI Overview at the very top. 27 of them named specific businesses. Google also showed a map with four businesses and their ratings for every search.

For trade businesses the Google Business Profile therefore matters twice: it is behind the map, and the AI Overview relied on directories and portals for 54% of its sources – where the same details should appear.

Where the recommendations come from

The four systems cited 354 sources in total. 49% were directories, review and city portals, 51% websites of individual businesses or other pages. The differences between the systems are large: Perplexity relied on portals for 82% of its sources, while ChatGPT and Gemini relied on websites for 70 to 75%.

Stacked bar chart of cited sources: ChatGPT 70 percent websites and 30 percent portals, Gemini 75 and 25, Perplexity 18 and 82, Google AI Overview 46 and 54 percent.
354 cited sources in 120 answers; classified by domain. Own analysis from 1 November 2026.
Most frequently cited sources
SourceCitations
elektriker.org20
werkenntdenbesten.de20
gelbeseiten.de13
trustlocal.de10
hamburg.de10
maler.org10
dastelefonbuch.de8
my-hammer.de8

A complete, up-to-date entry on the portals cited for customer questions in your city is therefore at least as important for trade businesses as your own website.

Painters, electricians, plumbers: differences per trade

The systems agreed most for painters: only one system named 85% of them, and 8 of 10 cities had at least one shared business. For electricians it was 90%, for plumbers 94% – with no overlap at all in 6 of 10 cities.

Bar chart: share of businesses named by only one AI system: painters 85 percent, electricians 90 percent, plumbers 94 percent.
10 cities × 4 AI systems each. Own analysis from 1 November 2026.
Results per trade
TradeBusinesses namedBy one system onlyCities without overlap
Painters9185%2 of 10
Electricians11490%3 of 10
Plumbers9894%6 of 10

The businesses at least two AIs named

Only 31 of the 303 businesses were named for the same question by at least two of the four AI systems. Here they are per trade, sorted by city, with the number of answers in which they appeared (4 per question).

Painters 14 businesses
  • Bönninger Maler GmbH & Co. KGDortmund · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Malermeisterbetrieb MünchhoffDortmund · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Malerbetrieb Sven WiesnerDüsseldorf · ChatGPT and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Tobias Mittler MalermeisterbetriebDüsseldorf · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Mike Netterdon MalerbetriebEssen · ChatGPT and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Frankfurter MalermeisterbetriebFrankfurt · Gemini and Perplexity · 2 of 4 answers
  • Malermeister RanklFrankfurt · ChatGPT and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Lange & HinzHamburg · ChatGPT and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Malermeisterin Annett JunghansLeipzig · ChatGPT and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Armagan GmbHMunich · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Heinrich SchmidMunich · Gemini and Perplexity · 2 of 4 answers
  • Richard Wörle GmbHMunich · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Heinrich Schmid GmbH & Co. KGStuttgart · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Maler Gerber GmbHStuttgart · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
Electricians 11 businesses
  • Elektro ReibschBerlin · Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 3 of 4 answers
  • Jäger ElektrotechnikDüsseldorf · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Elektro BarakaEssen · Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 3 of 4 answers
  • Elektro StruckEssen · ChatGPT and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Ay Elektrotechnik MeisterbetriebHamburg · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Elektrotechnik Thorsten BeckerHamburg · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Elektromontagen Leipzig GmbHLeipzig · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Elektrotechnik PaulickLeipzig · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Pittroff Elektrotechnik München GmbHMunich · Gemini and Perplexity · 2 of 4 answers
  • Bergmann Elektrotechnik GmbHStuttgart · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Elektro Gühring GmbHStuttgart · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
Plumbers 6 businesses
  • Lütge Haustechnik GmbHHamburg · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • heinen GmbHCologne · Gemini and Perplexity · 2 of 4 answers
  • Hentschel Meisterbetrieb für Sanitär-Heizung-LüftungLeipzig · Perplexity and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • M. Zankl GmbH & Co. KGLeipzig · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers
  • Andreas Lutz GmbHStuttgart · Gemini and Perplexity · 2 of 4 answers
  • Gauggel GmbHStuttgart · Gemini and Google AI Overview · 2 of 4 answers

This list is not a ranking. It shows who the AI systems named more than once in our sample – a new measurement may name others. We only link websites on which we found the name of the business ourselves on 6 November 2026. Something missing or wrong? Let us know and we will correct it.

What trade businesses can do now

  1. Keep your Google Business Profile complete. Every search showed a map with four businesses. Services, service area, opening hours, photos and recent reviews all count.
  2. Appear completely on the portals that get cited. Check which directories and review portals are cited for your customers’ questions and keep your entry there up to date. In this study these were mainly trade portals, review portals and business directories.
  3. State your service and location clearly on your website. ChatGPT and Gemini relied mostly on websites. A dedicated page per core service with its location gives them something concrete to cite – for example “Electrician in Essen-Rüttenscheid for wall boxes and solar” rather than “Your partner for electrical engineering”.
  4. Check more than one AI – regularly. Because the systems agree so rarely, a single test says little. Check your customers’ questions across several AIs and repeat it.

Whether ChatGPT names your business for typical customer questions, you can check with the free AI check in about a minute – without signing up.

Frequently asked questions

How many answers were analysed?

120 answers: ten cities, one question each about painters, electricians and plumbers, asked to ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overview on 1 November 2026.

Is the list of businesses a ranking?

No. We show the 31 businesses that at least two of the four AI systems named for the same question, sorted by trade and city. An order by mentions would be random: almost every business appeared in only one or two of the four answers, and AI recommendations change from week to week.

Do the apps answer like the APIs?

Not necessarily. In this study we measured the providers’ APIs; for Gemini, Perplexity provided the web search. The consumer apps can use other models and search sources. Since 3 November 2026 Nalqerio reads ChatGPT and Gemini in its daily measurement directly the way the apps answer.

My business is missing or linked wrongly. What can I do?

Write to us via the contact form and we will correct wrong links or spellings. The list only shows what the AI systems named in our measurement.

How can I check whether my business is named?

With the free AI check on nalqerio.com you see in about a minute whether ChatGPT names your business for two typical customer questions and who it names instead. Nalqerio measures your customers’ questions every morning across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Google AI Overview and Google AI Mode.

Sources and further reading

Methods, product scope and sources reflect the publication date shown. Examples are not measurements of your website. Linked product pages provide current plan and provider details.

Your next step

Investigate the questions that matter to your brand.

Put the guide into practice with your own business. Review answers and sources for your customer questions, organised in one project.

1 project5 customer questions1 AI snapshot
Start with a free, no-obligation trial Start your free 14-day trial €0 · no credit card · ends automaticallyCompare plans and allowances